10 Best Hotels in Cape May NJ 2025: The Ultimate Guide

Cape May, New Jersey, is a charming seaside town that has been a beloved destination for travelers seeking the perfect blend of history, natural beauty, and coastal allure. With its well-preserved Victorian architecture, pristine beaches, and a plethora of attractions, Cape May offers a wide range of accommodations to make your stay unforgettable. In this blog, we’ll explore the 10 best hotels in Cape May, New Jersey, in 2023, catering to various budgets and preferences.

1. Congress Hall

Address: 200 Congress Pl, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $250

Congress Hall is not just a hotel; it’s a historical landmark. Built in 1816, it’s one of the oldest seaside resorts in the United States. This grand, oceanfront hotel offers a delightful blend of classic charm and modern luxury. Guests can enjoy well-appointed rooms, beautiful views of the beach, and access to the hotel’s renowned restaurant and cocktail bar.

2. The Virginia Hotel

Address: 25 Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $200

The Virginia Hotel is an intimate and elegant boutique hotel nestled in the heart of Cape May. With its meticulously designed rooms and attention to detail, it provides an ideal romantic getaway. The Ebbitt Room, the hotel’s award-winning restaurant, offers delectable farm-to-table cuisine. The lovely garden courtyard is perfect for relaxation.

3. The Queen Victoria Bed & Breakfast

Address: 102 Ocean St, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $150

The Queen Victoria Bed & Breakfast is an exquisite collection of historic buildings that offer guests a taste of Victorian elegance. Each room is uniquely decorated, creating a charming and cozy atmosphere. The breakfast served here is renowned for its deliciousness, making it a great start to your day in Cape May.

4. The Southern Mansion

Address: 720 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $180

The Southern Mansion is a stately and beautifully restored mansion that exudes old-world charm. This boutique hotel offers luxurious accommodations and a stunning garden perfect for relaxation. The on-site restaurant, The Blue Rose Inn, serves delectable American cuisine in an elegant setting.

5. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

Address: 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $230

The Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is a beachfront destination that combines upscale accommodations with gourmet dining. The inn’s rooms are tastefully decorated, and some offer breathtaking ocean views. The on-site restaurant is known for its exquisite menu and romantic ambiance.

6. The Beach Shack

Address: 205 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $100

The Beach Shack provides a more relaxed and affordable option for travelers seeking the Cape May experience. This beachfront hotel offers a casual and comfortable atmosphere. The Rusty Nail, the on-site restaurant and bar, is a popular spot for guests and locals alike, making it a great place to unwind.

7. The Carroll Villa Hotel

Address: 19 Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $130

The Carroll Villa Hotel is a charming boutique hotel that’s been a part of Cape May’s history since 1882. With its beautifully decorated rooms and cozy atmosphere, it’s a favorite among travelers. The Mad Batter, the hotel’s restaurant, is a local institution known for its excellent cuisine and lively atmosphere.

8. La Mer Beachfront Inn

Address: 1317 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $170

La Mer Beachfront Inn offers travelers a comfortable and convenient beachfront experience. The hotel boasts rooms with private balconies that overlook the ocean. It’s the ideal choice for those who want to wake up to the sound of the waves and breathtaking sunrises.

9. The Mission Inn

Address: 1117 New Jersey Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $160

The Mission Inn is a unique and welcoming bed and breakfast known for its Spanish Revival architecture. This inn provides a tranquil atmosphere, with lovely gardens and comfortable rooms. It’s within walking distance of Cape May’s beautiful beaches and downtown area.

10. The Montreal Beach Resort

Address: 1025 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204

Price Range: From $160

The Montreal Beach Resort is conveniently located on the beach and close to Cape May’s attractions. The rooms are tastefully furnished, and the resort features an outdoor pool with ocean views. Guests can dine at Harry’s Ocean Bar & Grille, an on-site restaurant serving fresh seafood and other delightful dishes.

In Conclusion: A Diverse Range of Options

Cape May, New Jersey, is a destination that caters to various tastes and preferences, and its range of accommodations reflects that diversity. Whether you’re seeking a historic and luxurious hotel, a cozy bed and breakfast, or a more casual beachfront experience, Cape May has the perfect place to stay in 2025. With its rich history, beautiful architecture, and stunning coastal setting, Cape May invites you to explore its unique charm and create lasting memories.